R.A. Dickey had one of the more remarkable seasons in baseball history in 2012, winning the Cy Young Award after reinventing himself as a knuckleballer earlier in his career. Johan Santana, on the other hand, delivered an unforgettable moment that same season, pitching the first no-hitter in franchise history.
But which feat was more surprising?
On Friday's Baseball Night in New York: Living Room Edition, the crew answers that question.
Catch the full episode on SNY at 7 p.m.