It’s Friday night, Oct. 14, 2022, and the Mets and Dodgers are about to begin Game 3 of the National League Division Series. Just before 8 p.m., Daniel Murphy, superhero of the last Mets/Dodgers playoff showdown, emerges from the dugout to a wild ovation to throw the ceremonial first pitch.
It’s a sublime moment at Citi Field, but the Mets manage to top it two weeks later, when David Wright makes his long-awaited return to Queens for his own first pitch to open the World Series.
Wright jogs to the mound, waves to all corners of the ballpark, then throws a strike to, say, Pete Alonso, crouching behind the plate. It is the perfect conclusion to a season that invited so many Mets alumni back into the family.
Neither of these moments will happen, of course. But they actually might have. They were ideas being kicked around for a magical present that suddenly, abruptly, became unrealized fantasy.
That is what happens to every playoff team that fails to win the World Series: a day begins with excitement and runs on adrenaline. Plans are underway in the front office, clubhouse and executive suites for how to make the month special. Then it all just ends.
For players, it’s the sudden dissolution of temporary fraternity, or summer camp ending a week before it was supposed to. For fans, it's spending the spring and summer engrossed in a novel, falling in love with the characters and finding the last chapter ripped out.
For Max Scherzer, the spiritual leader of these new Mets despite his playoff clunker, it’s “a kick in the balls,” as he put it an hour or so after the San Diego Padres eliminated his team.
A playoff loss raises natural questions about the team’s future. It asks for interpretation and commentary. For these few hundred words, though, let’s not manufacture an opinion on whether the season ended with a horrible or modest disappointment. Let’s not wonder about Jacob deGrom’s contract, or Brandon Nimmo’s.