Last spring, when Gerrit Cole had his elbow checked, levels of concern inside the Yankees organization were moderate, even cautiously optimistic. Cole was just being thorough, team officials thought, making sure that he did not need surgery.

As it turned out, he did not. But the year was still weird.

This time around, the mood is far more bleak, and tilting toward hopelessness. As of this writing on Monday morning, the Yankees do not know for certain that their ace will need Tommy John surgery. But they are bracing for it with a quiet resignation that comes after a year of strong hints at this outcome.

Really, the bread crumbs have been there ever since Cole returned to the big leagues in late June. Covering the Yankees, I’d wondered all summer and fall if the team and Cole were bracing for this outcome.

Consider:

-- Cole threw his slider just seven percent of the time last season, by far the lowest total of his career. Always thoughtful and evolving, he had strategic reasons for this alteration of repertoire, but one couldn’t help but wonder if he was also holding back on snapping off that biting slider for fear of blowing out his elbow.

-- Manager Aaron Boone encountered fan and media criticism for pulling Cole at 88 pitches in the seventh inning of Game 1 of the World Series. But team sources said that Boone was actually pushing Cole that night, not acting conservatively. "Cole was gassed after the sixth," a source said. The natural question, unanswerable at the time: why?

-- In early November, Cole exercised an opt-out clause in his contract. This had been long expected, as was the Yankees response of voiding the opt out by adding a tenth year to Cole’s previously nine-year deal. Only they didn’t. The team told Cole that it was only comfortable keeping him under the current terms. Again: why?

-- A month later, the Yankees signed free agent ace Max Fried to an eight-year, $218 million contract.

Popular in the Community