Which star should Knicks pursue after not landing Donovan Mitchell?

Knicks have the draft capital to trade for some top talent

9/2/2022, 4:30 PM

With the Knicks failing to acquire Donovan Mitchell, the question of which star can the franchise pursue next is now more important than ever.

Barring a big leap out of RJ Barrett, New York is without the elite talent required to build a true contender around, and likely won’t lose enough games to find that guy in the draft.

Thankfully, the NBA is unpredictable and stars that appear untouchable one day are disgruntled the next. There’s always another one looking for an out, and an increasingly competent Knicks franchise seeking out their savior should be an attractive destination.

Here are some trade and free agency targets the Knicks could target as their next star.

Deandre Ayton

Phoenix matched Ayton’s restricted offer sheet with the Indiana Pacers after refusing to extend him and clashing with their young star. These aren’t the best terms to continue a partnership on and it would be of little surprise if Ayton is on the move once eligible.

While he’s not had the opportunity to be a No. 1 option, he has proven himself a strong defensive anchor and skilled 20-point scorer in deep playoff runs. He’s also just 24 years old, matching the young Knicks timeline well, and fits on the court as a big who can stretch beyond the paint.

A trade package centered around Julius Randle, Mitchell Robinson and (lots of) picks could satisfy both teams.

Jan 7, 2019; Portland, OR, USA; Portland Trail Blazers guard Damian Lillard (0) passes the ball during the second half against the New York Knicks at the Moda Center. The Blazers won 111-101. Mandatory Credit: Steve Dykes-USA TODAY Sports / © Steve Dykes-USA TODAY Sports
Jan 7, 2019; Portland, OR, USA; Portland Trail Blazers guard Damian Lillard (0) passes the ball during the second half against the New York Knicks at the Moda Center. The Blazers won 111-101. Mandatory Credit: Steve Dykes-USA TODAY Sports / © Steve Dykes-USA TODAY Sports

Damian Lillard

With credit to Portland’s quick retooling this past year, the clock remains ticking on Lillard’s patience with the franchise. The Knicks can’t bank on a trade request, but they should be prepared in case one happens in the next couple of years, which wouldn’t come as a shock given recent close calls.

Lillard is on the wrong side of 30 and would likely require the Knicks to trade Jalen Brunson, but few other stars of this caliber have made themselves almost-available to the Knicks. Ideally, he’d bring someone along in free agency or New York would have another trade ready to strengthen the core around him.

If Dame wants out, and Portland looks to cash in for its rebuild, New York will have the picks and prospects for it. Just expect a package similar, if not greater, to the one Utah received for Mitchell.

Bradley Beal

Trade murmurs circled Beal for seemingly years now, though he’s remained content, perhaps to secure the max extension Washington offered him this offseason. Another year of falling short of the postseason could drive him to want out.

He’s not the caliber of player Lillard is and is a bit older than Mitchell, but Beal would offer the Knicks an elite scoring package to build around. He averaged 30 points in back-to-back seasons before last year, including in his first-round loss to the 76ers in 2021.

Once again, this wouldn’t be a cheap package and New York would need to retain enough assets or have the cap space to net another high-level player to round out a contending roster.

Zion Williamson

Another name we’ve heard a ton in trade rumors, this time with many evident links to New York. We’ve also had past reports of some friction between him and his current franchise, something to watch out for.

Should Williamson want out, or New Orleans get cold feet over his health, a monster package of Randle, filler, prospects and picks could reunite him with college teammates Barrett and Cam Reddish. Their timelines fit nicely and should make for as dynamic a grouping in the NBA as they did in college.

Shai Gilgeous-Alexander

There hasn’t been any real intel on SGA wanting out, but any star entering his prime in the tank capitol of the sports world after tasting the playoffs in years past has to consider the grass might be greener elsewhere. Not to mention the team’s drafting of Josh Giddey has sidelined SGA from more point guard duties and could impact things.

The Knicks would need to offer up a Mitchell-sized package, which may not even suit Oklahoma City given they already have a million picks every year. His fit would be tremendous as a two-way guard who can play both positions, adaptable to any roster the Knicks may have at the time. He’s also just 24 years old.

Free agency 2023 and 2024

If the trade market doesn’t prove fruitful, there’s always the free agent pool. While it’s impossible to predict who is going to opt out of player options or turn down extensions, let alone want to play for the Knicks, here are some of the names that could become available over the next two summers.

Khris Middleton, James Harden, Kyrie Irving, LeBron James, Paul George, Kawhi Leonard, Klay Thompson, Pascal Siakam, Jaylen Brown, OG Anunoby and Dejounte Murray. Obviously, these names vary wildly in age and talent, but all would look good to the Knicks right about now.

New York may have trouble carving out cap space with rookie extensions coming due and multiple players locked in long-term, but they’ve proven they can move off contracts when needed, as they did to sign Brunson.

If one of these players expresses real interest, expect the Knicks to jump on the opportunity if they haven’t found a star yet.

Popular in the Community