"Obviously we've scuffled here as of recent, but we've been having quality at-bats for the better part of the year," Donaldson told reporters after the game. "Obviously that's why we've won a lot of games. I think that's just who we are. I think that inning is just who we are as a team."
Anthony Rizzo, who walked to set up the bases-loaded situation for Donaldson, added: "It feels nice just the way we won. That's really the team we've been for the most part of this year. Just feels good."
We may look back at this being the turning point of the Yankees' season, getting back to their first-half identity and cruising to an AL East title.
It all depends on how they respond to this improbable win moving forward.
Because when you look back at this game, we see situations that have been costing the Yankees, like Gleyber Torres swinging at the first pitch in the bottom of the seventh with the bases loaded and one out, resulting in a double play to kill a rally. Aaron Judge had walked on four pitches in the previous at-bat to make it a 4-3 game. The Yanks could've pulled away in that situation if he were more patient.
Going back to Chapman, while Mejia's hit could be viewed as some bad luck, he had a four-pitch walk to Isaac Paredes and a walk to Taylor Walls to load the bases before that happened. With Clay Holmes on the IL now, the Yankees can't afford for him to regress to the wildly inconsistent reliever he's been. Chapman actually looked good prior to this appearance.
You could even make the argument that Aaron Boone's call to pinch hit Aaron Hicks for Isiah Kiner-Falefa, when Hicks has been struggling mightily this month, wasn't the right managerial call to make. But Hicks, from the left side of the plate, worked the count and almost produced a walk in the bottom of the ninth, which is likely what Boone was thinking. Can't blame him for that when Kiner-Falefa was already 0-for-3 on the night with a strikeout.
Though those moments are reminiscent of what's been happening to the Yanks, there were some clutch at-bats that kept them in the game in the first place. As much as Torres dropped the ball in the bottom of the seventh, he hit the Yankees' first homer in quite some time in the inning before, making it a 4-2 game.